Anglican Unscripted Episode 72, May 18, 2013 May 18, 2013
Posted by geoconger in Abuse, Anglican Church of Australia, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Church of Tanzania, Anglican.TV, Church of England, Church of Nigeria, The Episcopal Church.Tags: Boko Haram, gay marriage, Jacob Chimeledya, Valentino Mokiwa, Wallace Benn
add a comment
Episode 72 of Anglican Unscripted brings even more news about the Anglican Church (Communion) around the world. Kevin and George talk about stories from Tanzania and Nigeria, who are dealing with internal conflict and Muslim-on-Christian violence.
It is also time to give an update on the Temporary Same Sex Liturgies the Episcopal Church passed at General Convention last year and who is using them and who is not.
AS Haley updates all the major legal cases around the country and discusses the late breaking news from The Falls Church.
Peter Ould talks about the growing conflict and investigation in Jersey. It is hard to tell if the biggest issue is jurisdiction or lack of trasparency.
Finally, in the blooper real at the end of the episode (after the credits) one of our contributors reveals a hidden talent. #AU72 Comments to AnglicanUnscripted@gmail.com
Anglican Unscripted, Episode 71, May 10. 2013 May 14, 2013
Posted by geoconger in The Episcopal Church, Anglican Church of Aotearoa New Zealand & Polynesia, Property Litigation, San Joaquin, Los Angeles, Quincy, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV.Tags: Diocese of Niagara, Michael Bird, St James Newport Beach
add a comment
In this week’s Episode your host talk about the latest legal heartbreak in California. Also this week, there is late breaking international news about a Bishop who accidentally invokes Scripture. AU’s Legal segment covers all of the court cases in the US, and Kevin interviews David Jenkins about his lawsuit from Bishop Byrd. #AU71 Comments: AnglicanUnscripted@gmail.com
Anglican Unscripted Episode 68, March 22, 2013 March 22, 2013
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, Church of England, The Episcopal Church.comments closed
Dust off the Herald Trumpet and dry clean your vestments as we have a new Pope and a new Archbishop of Canterbury this week, meanwhile your AU hosts refuse to gush and talk at the same time. Also this week there are more details regarding the scandal over the elections in Tanzania and news from the Jersey shore… the other Jersey shore. Kevin talks with a special guest and George breaks next weeks top story this week. Comments to anglicanunscripted@gmail.com and tweet: #AU68
Additional Complaints Filed in Tanzania: Anglican Ink, March 7, 2013 March 7, 2013
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Church of Tanzania, Anglican Ink, Corruption, GAFCON, The Episcopal Church.Tags: Jacobo Chimeledya, Valentino Mokiwa
comments closed
Three complaints have been lodged with the Anglican Church of Tanzania (ACT) by members of the church’s general synod alleging misconduct and fraud in the conduct of last month’s election of an archbishop.
On 3 March 2013 Dr Dickson Chilongani, Provincial Secretary of the ACT, released a statement announcing the election of the Rt. Rev. Jacob Erasto Chimeledya “as the new Archbishop of the Anglican Church of Tanzania.”
…
However supporters of the sitting archbishop, Valentino Mokiwa of Dar es Salaam, cried foul. A 27 Feb 2013 complaint seen by AI has alleged eight constitutional irregularities in the voting, including the casting of four more ballots than electors present. The claim put forward by Dr. Chilongani was ingenuous, they added, stating that while the House of Bishops may have endorsed the election, the Lay and Clergy Houses of Synod had not.
Read it all in Anglican Ink
ACNA to review women’s orders: The Church of England Newspaper, January 20, 2013 p 6 January 25, 2013
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper, Women Priests.comments closed
The College of Bishops of the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) has agreed to launch a Task Force examining the question of the Holy Orders of women clergy. Meeting last week in Orlando, the ACNA bishops set down a five part protocol studying the question of women clergy in conjunction with the issues of Prayer Book reform, the creation of a Catechism for the church, and a review of its ecclesial structures.
In ordering their priorities, the bishops decided to begin with a study of Scripture and church traditions and them move to the creation of church policies. One bishops told The Church of England Newspaper the ACNA bishops wanted to ground their actions in doctrine, rather than find a doctrine to support their actions.
The election and translation of five bishops were approved by the College of Bishops, while time was also spent seeking to heal the hurts caused by the break-up of the Anglican Mission in America last year.
The ACNA currently permits dioceses to ordain women to the diaconate and priesthood, but not to the episcopate. However, Forward in Faith and the Anglo-Catholic Diocese of San Joaquin have urged the province to review its “two integrities” structure.
The bishops announced they had appointed a task force to study the doctrine of Holy Orders – not limiting their work to the question of women clergy – and would begin by with the Bible and then move to a study of doctrine and tradition.
At Phase 4 “the Task Force will discuss the arguments, pro and con, related to the ordination of women, considering the relevant Scriptural texts and historical arguments, and reviewing studies conducted within and without the Anglican tradition.”
The College of Bishops said that before final action is taken, their recommendations will be passed to the theological commission of the Fellowship of Confessing Anglicans. The conservative reform movement within the Anglican Communion is divided on the question of women clergy with Uganda, Kenya and Rwanda strongly in favor, while Singapore, Sydney and the Anglo-Catholic provinces of Africa are opposed.
A report on overlapping dioceses and episcopal jurisdictions was also presented to the College. A communique from the meeting stated the ACNA sought to bring the church into conformity “with historic Anglican practice. The goal of the work is to organize each region for the long-term sustainability of the movement in recognizable, godly Anglican Church structures.”
The bishops received a map showing the location of each of the their 951 congregations, which enabled the bishops to identify “11 regions of overlapping mission work among the various jurisdictions of the Province.”
While no diocese or group was slated for elimination, the bishops’ communique stated the challenge of overlapping jurisdictions “will result in enhanced collaboration, responsive structures and ministry oversight, with better sharing of resources, clearer communication and more profound unity in the mission that we share.”
Women clergy under review for the ACNA: Anglican Ink, January 11, 2013 January 11, 2013
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, House of Bishops, Women Priests.comments closed
More bishops, fewer dioceses and the future of women clergy were amongst the main topics of debate at the Anglican Church of North America’s College of Bishops meeting this week in Orlando.
Bishops from the conservative province in waiting in North America in the Anglican Communion approved the election of two additional bishops for the PEAR-USA Network. The Rev. Quigg Lawrence will lead the Atlantic Regional Network and the Rev. Ken Ross the Western Regional Network, while the Very Rev. Clark Lowenfield was elected bishop of the Diocese of the Western Gulf Coast – a diocese in formation.
The bishops also confirmed the election of the Rt. Rev. Charlie Masters as bishop coadjutor of the Anglican Network in Canada and approved the translation of the Rt. Rev. Frank Lyons from the Diocese of Bolivia to the Diocese of Pittsburgh as assistant bishop.
Time was also spent in mending fences amongst the College between the three former members of the Anglican Mission in America and the wider ACNA, following the protracted break up of the group.
A report on overlapping dioceses and episcopal jurisdictions was also presented to the College. A communique from the meeting stated the ACNA sought to bring the church into conformity “with historic Anglican practice. The goal of the work is to organize each region for the long-term sustainability of the movement in recognizable, godly Anglican Church structures.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Papal meeting for Anglican conservatives: The Church of England Newspaper, January 6, 2013 p 3. January 4, 2013
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper, Roman Catholic Church.Tags: Eliud Wabukala, Fellowship of Confessing Anglicans, Pope Benedict XVI, Ray Sutton, Robert Duncan
comments closed

Archbishop Robert Duncan (centre) and Bishop Ray Sutton (right) of the ACNA at the 28 Nov 2012 General Audience with Pope Benedict XVI
The leader of the Fellowship of Confessing Anglicans, Archbishop Eliud Wabukala of Kenya, held a private meeting last month at the Vatican with Pope Benedict XVI.
On 28 Nov 2012, Archbishop Wabukala, Archbishop Robert Duncan and Bishop Ray Sutton of the Anglican Church in North America, along with a retired bishop from the Church of England met with Benedict and officials from the curia in private after the Wednesday General Audience.
Details of the conversation have not been released however, Benedict has long held an interest in the internal workings of the Anglican Communion. In October 2003, as President of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger sent a letter of encouragement on behalf of Pope John Paul II to those attending the “Plano Conference” of conservative Episcopalians in Dallas, Texas, who had gathered to voice their opposition to the impending consecration of Gene Robinson as Bishop of New Hampshire.
Pope Benedict has also focused much of his energies on Africa. A recent issue of the Jesuit magazine La Civiltà Cattolica stated the pope has referred to Africa as to the “lung” of the Catholic Church and the church in Africa was “currently the most dynamic continent from the point of view of the expansion of the Church and of Christianity in general, and where vocations are the most numerous in terms of percentage.”
Travel delays prevented Archbishop Wabukala from attending the General Audience with Archbishop Duncan and Bishop Sutton, though the archbishop and other leaders of the global reform movement within the Anglican Communion were present at the afternoon’s private session.
Connecticut school shooting leaves America in mourning: The Church of England Newspaper, December 23, 2012 p 7. December 28, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper, Connecticut, Crime, The Episcopal Church.Tags: Adam Lanza, Newtown shooting
comments closed
Church leaders in the United States have responded with horror to last week’s Connecticut school shooting, calling upon Anglicans to turn towards God in prayer in response to the murder of 26 people – including 20 school children.
On 14 Dec 2012, Adam Lanza (20), shot and killed his mother at their home and then proceeded to her workplace, the Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut. Police have yet to release a timeline of events, but armed with a variety of pistols taken from his mother’s home, Lanza entered the school killing six teachers and administrators and the members of his mother’s class – 20 children ranging in age from 5 to 7 years of age.
Lanza then took his own life before police arrived on the scene. The motive for the killings is unknown as are details of the killer’s life – though acquaintances described the young man as troubled.
Archbishop Robert Duncan of the Anglican Church in North America urged his flock to pray for the victims and their families. “Please join us in praying for the victims of and families affected by Friday’s shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, CT. “Grant us grace fearlessly to contend against evil and to make no peace with oppression; and, that we may reverently use our freedom, help us to employ it in the maintenance of justice in our communities and among the nations,” he wrote.
Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori wrote the Episcopal Church grieved with those who had died and mourned the loss “of lives so young and innocent. We grieve that the means of death are so readily available to people who lack the present capacity to find other ways of responding to their own anger and grief. We know that God’s heart is broken over this tragedy, and the tragedies that unfold each and every day across this nation. And we pray that this latest concentration of shooting deaths in one event will awaken us to the unnoticed number of children and young people who die senselessly across this land every day.”
Speaking at a memorial service in Newtown High School on 16 December, President Barack Obama said he was “very mindful that words cannot match the depths of your sorrow, but whatever measure of comfort we can provide, we will provide. … Newtown, you are not alone.”
“These tragedies must end, and to end them we must change,” the president said, saying he would call upon law enforcement and mental health experts to “prevent another tragedy like this.”
The shooting has prompted a national debate over the causes of “rampage” killings, with some blaming a changing culture, others loose gun control laws, while others have questioned state programs of closing state mental hospitals in favor of community care.
In statement released after the shootings on Friday, the Bishop of Washington Mariann Budde announced that she was “calling on our national leaders to enact more effective gun control measures. We know from experience that such calls go unheeded. But what if this time, you and I took up this issue and wouldn’t put it down until something was done? . . . Today we grieve, but soon we act.”
However, conservative columnist Mona Charen argued the problem also lay in failed health policies as “misplaced civil libertarianism and romanticization of mental illness led to deinstitutionalization” of the mentally ill so that “now, 95 percent of the inpatient beds we had in 1955 are gone.”
There were a “a small subset of mentally ill people who are dangerous. They are responsible for an estimated 50 percent of rampage killings. In the name of personal autonomy, we have made it almost impossible to force them to get treatment. The horrifying consequences are all around us,” she said.
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
Hiltz calls on Canterbury to say “no” to the ACNA: Anglican Ink, December 19, 2012 December 20, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of Canada, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Communion, Anglican Consultative Council, Archbishop of Canterbury, Church of England Newspaper.Tags: Fred Hiltz, Justin Welby
comments closed

The Archbishop of Canterbury-designate Justin Welby and Archbishop Fred Hiltz of Canada
The leader of the Anglican Church of Canada has lobbied the Archbishop of Canterbury-designate not to extend formal recognition to the Anglican Church in North America. However, the decision who is an Anglican does not rest with the Archbishop of Canterbury. The communion’s formal statement as to who is an Anglican looks to fellowship with the Archbishop of Canterbury and fidelity to the doctrines and disciplines set forth in the Book of Common Prayer.
The 6 Dec 2012 meeting at Auckland Castle, Durham with Bishop Justin Welby was one of four stops for Archbishop Fred Hiltz, who also met with the Archbishop of Canterbury Dr. Rowan Williams at Lambeth Palace and with the general secretary of the Anglican Consultative Council, Canon Kenneth Kearon, in London, and preached at Southwark Cathedral.
According to the Anglican Journal, Archbishop Hiltz said he mentioned his ongoing concern about efforts by the ACNA to be recognized by the Church of England. Archbishop Hiltz said he requested that if bodies of the Church of England are to meet with representatives of ACNA, “in fairness, they should also meet with us to get a better picture.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Papal meeting for conservative Anglican leaders: Anglican Ink, December 11, 2012 December 12, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Anglican Ordinariate, Roman Catholic Church.Tags: Benedict XVI, Eluid Wabukala, Jeffrey Steenson, Ray Sutton, Robert Duncan
comments closed

At the close of the General Audience of 28 Nov 2012, the leader of the Anglican Church in North America, Archbishop Robert Duncan met with Pope Benedict XVI at the Vatican.
Archbishop Eliud Wabukala of Kenya, leader of the Fellowship of Confessing Anglicans, was to have also attended the General Audience, but was delayed. Joined by the chairman of the ACNA’s ecumenical relations commission, Bishop Ray Sutton of the Reformed Episcopal Church, Archbishop Duncan spoke with the pope. The three later met with Vatican officials. Details of the conversations have not been released. Claims of the significance of the meeting or of its symbolism are also premature, one Vatican watcher said, until the substance of the conversation is known.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
REC proclaims second cathedral for Diocese of Mid America: Anglican Ink, December 11, 2012 December 12, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Reformed Episcopal Church.Tags: Diocese of Mid America, Ray Sutton, Royal Grote
comments closed

The Reformed Episcopal Church has proclaimed its second cathedral for the Diocese of Mid America. At an evensong service on 2 Dec 2012, Bishop Royal Grote announced that the Church of the Holy Communion in Dallas, Texas had been named a pro cathedral for the diocese which covers 18 central and mid-western states.
In his address, Bishop Grote recognized the significant role of leadership that Holy Communion and its rector, the Rt. Rev. Ray Sutton – the bishop coadjutor of the diocese, had played in the development of the Diocese.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Church of England will not break with South Carolina: Anglican Ink, November 19, 2012 November 20, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Church of England, South Carolina.Tags: Christopher Hill, General Synod, Mark Lawrence
comments closed
.jpg)
The Church of England has declined to accept Presiding Bishop Katherine Jefferts Schori’s assertion the Diocese of South Carolina may not withdraw from the Episcopal Church. Nor will Saturday’s vote by the South Carolina Special Convention affect the standing of its clergy with the Church of England at this time, General Synod learned today.
Speaking for the church’s Council for Christian Unity (CCU), Bishop Christopher Hill said the Church of England sought to maintain good relations with all sides in the Episcopal Church’s civil war and would take no “hasty” actions at this time.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Charlie Masters elected Bishop of ANiC: Anglican Ink, November 15, 2012 November 15, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink.Tags: Charlie Masters
comments closed

Bishop Gerald Mpango speaking to Bishop Charlie Masters in Dar es Salaam
The Anglican Network in Canada (ANiC) synod has elected the Rt. Rev. Charles Masters to be bishop coadjutor of the Anglican Church in North America’s diocese in Canada.
Delegates to the ANiC synod meeting representing the ANiC’s 69 congregations and 4000 active members met at SS Peter and Paul Anglican Church in Ottawa on 14 November 2012 to select a successor to Bishop Donald Harvey, who has announced his retirement.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Bribery allegations false, Archbishop declares: Anglican Ink, November 13, 2012 November 14, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Church of Rwanda, Anglican Ink, Corruption.Tags: Chuck Murphy, Onesphore Rwaje, PEAR-USA
comments closed

The Most Rev. Onesphore Rwaje, Archbishop of Rwanda
Allegations the Archbishop of the Anglican Church of Rwanda (PEAR) solicited a $250,000 gratuity from the Anglican Mission in America and its refusal led to the breach with the African church are baseless, church leaders tell Anglican Ink.
Rumors have circulated on the internet for the past few days accusing the Rwandan primate of graft. “I learned from an unimpeachable source today that Rwandan Archbishop Rwaje had asked Bishop Chuck Murphy for $250,000 to build a home,” one message shared on a popular Anglican news portal alleged.
Speculation attached to the rumor said the refusal of Bishop Murphy to agree to the shakedown might have been behind his “downfall from Rwanda.”
Archbishop Onesphore Rwaje of Rwanda told Anglican Ink the accusations were “not true.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
All Saints Pawleys Island votes to join the ACNA: Anglican Ink, November 9, 2012 November 9, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink.Tags: All Saints Pawleys Island, Rob Grafe
comments closed

All Saints Pawleys Island
Anglican Mission in America has voted to join the Anglican Church of North America (ACNA).
At a parish meeting on 5 Nov 2012, All Saints Church in Pawleys Island, South Carolina was asked to give its support to one of two propositions. Proposal 1 would affiliate the historic congregation with the ACNA, while proposal 2 would align the church with the Anglican Mission in America’s (AMiA) Society for Mission and Apostolic Works.
Parish by laws required 51 per cent approval for a change in affiliation or 316 votes. With a quorum present, proposal 1 received 322 votes and proposal 2 received 229 votes.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Virginia Supreme Court accepts Falls Church appeal: Anglican Ink, October 29, 2012 October 29, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Property Litigation, Virginia.Tags: The Falls Church, Virginia Supreme Court
comments closed

The Falls Church
A three-member writ panel of the Virginia Supreme Court has voted to review the case of the Episcopal Church v. The Falls Church.
On 26 October 2012 the court’s website stated it had “granted” The Falls Church’s petition for appeal of the March 2012 order issued by Virginia Circuit Court Judge Randy I. Bellows granting trusteeship of the property and control of the congregation’s assets to the Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Virginia.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 52: October 12, 2012 October 12, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Episcopal Church of Brazil, Anglican.TV, Church of England, Church of Ireland.Tags: Charles Bennison, Diocese of Recife, Richard Clarke
comments closed
Kevin and George bring the latest Anglican News from around the world. This week they discuss the state of Religious News Reporting, the retirement of Charles Bennison, the new Archbishop of Canterbury, Vatican II and much much more. Twitter #AU52 Comments to AnglicanUnscripted@gmail.com
Recife elects new bishop: The Church of England Newspaper, September 30, 2012 p 6. October 2, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Episcopal Church of Brazil, Church of England Newspaper, La Iglesia Anglicana del Cono Sur de America.Tags: Diocese of Recife, Miguel Uchoa
comments closed
Bishop-elect Miguel Uchoa of Recife
The rector of the largest Anglican parish in South America has been elected Bishop of Recife. On 15 Sept 2012 the Rev. Miguel Ângelo de Andrade Uchoa Cavalcanti, rector of the Paróquia Anglicana Espírito Santo in Jaboatão dos Guararapes in the state of Pernambuco was elected fourth bishop of the diocese in succession to the late Dr. Robinson Cavalcanti.
Two candidates stood for election and on the first ballot Fr. Uchoa received 79.5 per cent of the lay and 69.3 per cent of the clergy votes from the 58 lay and 52 clergy delegates present, defeating the rival candidate, suffragan Bishop Evilásio Tenório. In 2005, the bishop and almost all of the Recife clergy were expelled from the Anglican Episcopal Church of Brazil. Bishop Cavalcanti, his clergy and approximately 90 per cent of the congregations moved under the oversight of the Anglican Province of the Southern Cone and are linked to the Anglican Church in North America.
In a statement released after the synod, Bishop-elect Uchoa said he was humbled by his election. It was now his duty to “fulfill God’s call to this new phase of my life and ministry. But, I must emphasize, that the call does not just happen in my life. It is a call to our diocese, for the people, the clergy, the leaders of all communities, for the whole Church of Christ gathered in the Diocese of Recife” to “serve God and to align with His perfect will.”
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
Virginia Supreme Court schedules hearing for The Falls Church case September 26, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Property Litigation, The Episcopal Church, Virginia.comments closed

The Rev. John Yates and The Falls Church
The Supreme Court of Virginia has directed The Falls Church to present oral argument to a writ panel on 16 October 2012 in support of its petition to throw out a lower court decision turning over its property to the Diocese of Virginia.
In a 25 September 2012 statement, Henry Burt, secretary of the Diocese of Virginia said The Falls Church attorneys will be given ten minutes of oral argument to “persuade the Court to hear their appeal on the merits. The Supreme Court will decide whether it will hear the case in a few weeks after the hearing. If the appeal is accepted for argument, it is likely to be heard in the first half of next year.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 49, September 13, 2012 September 14, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, Archbishop of Canterbury, Church of England, South Carolina.Tags: Richard Chartres, Robert Duncan, Rowan Williams
comments closed
Kevin and George are back from news blackout break with Anglican News from around the globe. They discuss Rowan’s exit interview, South Carolina, Archbishop Duncan’s interview and Much, Much More. #AU49 Comments to AnglicanUnscripted@gmail.com There might even be some bloopers.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 48, August 18, 2012 August 18, 2012
Posted by geoconger in 77th General Convention, AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, Archbishop of Canterbury, Archbishop of York, Canon Law, Church of England, Church of the Province of Uganda, Church of the Province of West Africa, South Carolina.Tags: Crown Nominations Committee
comments closed
Not a week goes by (even in August) when the Unscripted team can’t dig up some interesting news. Kevin and George discuss the “new thang” with AMiA and the turmoil at Pawley’s Island. They also reveal some Crown Commission secrets, Anglican Job Postings and Affinity Dioceses. Peter Ould talks about an Englishman trying to sell more books and Allan gives some interesting history about leaving and staying in TEC at the same time.
All Saints Pawleys Island may go ACNA: Anglican Ink, July 30, 2012 July 31, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink.Tags: All Saints Pawleys Island, Chuck Murphy, Robert L Grafe Jr.
comments closed
The flagship parish of the Anglican Mission in America – All Saints Pawleys Island – is set to vote at a special parish meeting this fall on its rector’s proposal the congregation join the Anglican Church in North America.
The Rev. Robert L. Grafe, Jr., rector of the founding parish of the AMiA, told Anglican Ink his congregation was entering a “season of prayer and discernment.”
He noted that a “change in affiliation requires an amendment to our by-laws and a parish vote,” which could take place later this year.
In a 27 July 2012 letter to the congregation, Mr. Grafe wrote that in the wake of the December split within the AMiA “it became clear that there would be other Anglican options for affiliation to consider.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Fort Worth files Motion for Expedited Oral Argument: Anglican Ink, July 6, 2012 July 7, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Fort Worth, Property Litigation.comments closed
Attorneys for Bishop Jack Iker and the Episcopal Diocese of Fort Worth have filed a Motion for Expedited Oral Argument with the Texas Supreme Court to adjudicate its property dispute with the national Episcopal Church and its Episcopal Diocese of Fort Worth.
The motion filed on 6 July 2012 noted that on 23 April “an amicus brief was filed in this case by seven bishops and three priests of The Episcopal Church (TEC). The brief supported the Fort Worth Diocese’s arguments that, should Texas adopt the Deference approach rather Neutral Principles for church property disputes, the final authority in the Episcopalian tradition on such disputes is the local bishop, not TEC’s national administrative office.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 43, June 18, 2012 June 18, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Church of Rwanda, Anglican Covenant, Anglican.TV, Canon Law, Church of England, Church of Ireland, Property Litigation, Scottish Episcopal Church.Tags: U.S. Supreme Court
comments closed
After a one week hiatus George and Kevin return. Allan Haley brings breaking news from the Supreme Court concerning TEC churches and the Dennis Canon. Your hosts talk about their adventures at the Anglican Church in North America’s Assembly, including the topic everyone was ‘not’ talking about. David Ould brings news from Australia and England while his twin brother Peter is enjoying a vacation with is family at Eurodisney.
No inter-communion for conservative Anglicans and Lutherans in North America: The Church of England Newspaper, June 10, 2012 p 7. June 13, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper.Tags: Lutheran Church Canada, Lutheran Church Missouri Synod
comments closed
The Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) and the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod and the Lutheran Church—Canada have released a joint statement of pastoral principles, but were unable to enter into inter-communion due to the historic doctrinal and ecclesial differences between Anglicans and Lutherans.
On 25 May 2012, the leaders of the three churches released a statement summarizing 18 months of talks. While they shared common moral views, doctrine divided the conservative Lutheran churches from the ACNA.
The President of the LCMS – an American Lutheran denomination 2.3 million baptized members in more than 6,000 congregations – Dr. Matthew Harrison stated that “in a time when there is a widespread failure to recognize the biblical teaching regarding the creation of man and woman and their biblical roles, life-issues, and other grave challenges that society faces, it is a joy to find a group of Christians within the Anglican Church in North America who affirm this biblical teaching, and who desire to cooperate in externals with the Missouri Synod in upholding the biblical natural law in society.”
The ACNA’s Archbishop Robert Duncan stated that it was a “great blessing to be walking alongside” the LCMS as the two shared “an unwavering commitment to the authority of Scripture.”
“We look forward to continuing our work together for the Gospel through prayers, evangelism, dialogue, encouragement of one another, and joint efforts to help those in need,” Archbishop Duncan said.
The ACNA and the two conservative Lutheran churches shared a common view of the Trinity; professed the Apostles’, Nicene, and Athanasian Creeds; and “we recognize the Fall into sin and the reality that only by grace through faith in Christ can fallen human beings find justification and salvation. We rejoice together in one Baptism for the remission of sins and the new life given through this sacrament. In the confession of these truths, we also recognize and affirm that they are known through the Holy Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, the very Word of God written, which are the infallible basis for all church teaching.”
The churches also said that “we look toward the possibility of joint statements on important issues facing our churches and our culture such as questions about homosexuality and abortion. We also anticipate opportunities to work together to address human needs like hunger, homelessness, and other ministries of mercy toward those in crisis.”
However, the ACNA and the LCMS would not be able to enter into inter-communion as Anglicans did not subscribe to the historic Lutheran confessions.
“We recognize that further discussion is needed regarding issues of ecclesiology” the churches said, particularly the “office of bishop (its definition, nature, and necessity).”
“Disagreement exists among Anglicans about the propriety of ordaining women to the pastoral (presbyteral) office, while the LCMS opposes this practice”, and “We recognize that further discussion is needed regarding our respective understandings of the real presence of Christ in the Lord’s Supper and the administration of this sacrament.”
However, the churches were encouraged by what they had in common. Dr. Robert Bugbee, president of the Lutheran Church—Canada, stated: “Despite the decay in foundational Christian teaching among mainline churches in North America, the Lord is opening doors for us to encourage each other to root our work in the apostolic Gospel of Christ and in the Scriptures as God’s infallible Word.”
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
Property settlements in Ontario announced: The Church of England Newspaper, June 10, 2012 p 7. June 13, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of Canada, Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper.Tags: ANiC, Diocese of Niagara
comments closed

The congregation of St Hilda’s leaving church for the last time. Photo: David Jenkins
Three Ontario parishes of the ACNA have reached a settlement with the Diocese of Niagara to end five years of litigation following their secession from the Anglican Church of Canada.
On 31 May 2012 the Anglican Network in Canada (ANiC) announced that the congregations of St. George’s in Burlington, St. Hilda’s in Oakville and the Church of the Good Shepherd in St. Catharines would turn over their properties to the diocese on 1 June.
The agreement allowed the congregations to keep certain “worship, liturgical and memorial items”. Each party also agreed that it would be responsible for its own legal costs and would foreswear any further litigation.
The diocese also agreed to pay to one departing congregation the costs of recent property improvements. The diocese and congregations also agreed to share the proceeds from the sale of a rectory.
The three Niagara congregations were among a dozen parishes that voted in February 2008 to quit the Anglican Church of Canada and join ANiC. Canadian Archbishop Fred Hiltz condemned the departures, writing on 28 Feb 2008 that the defections were unnecessary.
The capacity for a “breadth of theological perspective” was part of the Anglican “heritage that we continue to cherish, Archbishop Hiltz said.
However, defections were been driven by a desire to remain Anglican, the executive director of ANiC told The Church of England Newspaper.
“If we did not offer them an option by the end of the year,” Cheryl Chang told the CEN, many said the “would leave Anglicanism altogether.”
The Diocese of Niagara did not respond to our query as of our going to press, but a warden at the Church of the Good Shepherd, Patricia Decker, stated the parish was “deeply grateful to God for this settlement which frees us from the threat of further litigation.”
Mrs. Decker stated the congregation was “not naïve about the challenges of continuing our ministry in temporary rented facilities, but these inconveniences are completely overshadowed by the joyful anticipation of new ministry opportunities and the blessings God has in store for us as we take this step.”
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
Women clergy and doctrine dividing the Orthodox from ACNA June 9, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Orthodox Church in America, Polish National Catholic Church, Women Priests.Tags: Metropolitan Jonah, Missouri Synod Lutheran Church, North American Lutheran Church
comments closed
Metropolitan Jonah of the OCA addressing the ACNA Assembly in Ridgecrest, NC on 8 June 2012
The Metropolitan of the Orthodox Church in America, His Beatitude Jonah has called upon the Anglican Church of North America to ditch women clergy, Calvinism and the filioque in the name of Christian unity.
This is an “opportunity to return your church to its original catholic heritage” Jonah told delegates attending the ACNA’s 2nd Assembly at the Lifeway Conference Center in Ridgecrest, NC on 8 June 2012.
The ACNA can “overcome generations of schism, a schism forced upon the English church” by Rome if it eliminates the filioque from the Nicene Creed, the Orthodox leader said. The Filioque – the phrase “and from the Son” is a clause found in the Western Christian Church but not in the Eastern Churches.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Alan Hawkings named Anglican 1000 vicar: Anglican Ink, June 7, 2012 June 7, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink.Tags: Alan Hawkins, Anglican 1000, Robert Duncan
comments closed
Archbishop Robert Duncan introducing the Rev. Alan Hawkins (left) to the ACNA Assembly as the Rt. Rev. Todd Hunter (right) looks on
The Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) has named the Rev. Alan Hawkins to serve as the Vicar of the Anglican 1000 movement, Archbishop Robert Duncan told delegates to the church’s 2nd Provincial Assembly.
Archbishop Duncan told delegates on the opening day of the 7-9 June 2012 meeting in Ridgecrest, N.C., that Mr. Hawkins, the rector of the Church of the Redeemer in Greensboro, NC, will supervise the province’s church planting initiative – a work the archbishop characterized as being the “central” program of the province.
In a statement released by the ACNA, Mr. Hawkins said it was “humbling and a privilege” to head up the work of Anglican 1000, the “cornerstone of the Anglican Church in North America and I look forward to being able to encourage and support the planting of new churches in our tradition throughout North America.”
At the 1st Provincial Assembly in 2009, Archbishop Duncan challenged the ACNA to plant 1000 congregations within five years. Assembly Archbishop Duncan called upon the ACNA to plant 1000 new congregations. The rector of Christ Church Plano, the Rev. Canon David Roseberry and the Rev. Daniel Adkinson answered the archbishop’s call by helping start a church planning program that has helped spur the ACNA’s rapid growth over the past three years.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
2011 a ‘challenge’ for the ACNA, Archbishop reports: Anglican Ink, June 7, 2012 June 7, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink.Tags: Robert Duncan
comments closed

Archbishop Duncan addressing the ACNA provincial council
The year 2011 could have been the Anglican Church in North America’s annus horribilis, Archbishop Robert Duncan told the bishop and delegates attending its fourth provincial council meeting at the Ridgecrest Conference Center in Western North Carolina on 6 June 2012.
But at year’s end the ACNA was the stronger for its engagement with the chaos surrounding the collapse of the Anglican Mission in America. “The only way to explain what has happened is to speak of God’s hand and God’s favor” the archbishop said in his presidential address.
While heavy fog greeted the bishops and council members at their mountain retreat, grey skies were not evident inside the council chamber. Delegates told Anglican Ink they were upbeat and hopeful for the future of the province-in-waiting of the Anglican Communion – a message shared by Archbishop Duncan in his state of the church address.
The archbishop opened his address by noting that although the past year had been a “challenge,” “greater unity globally has also been achieved.”
The ACNA’s relationship with the Church of Rwanda “has never been closer” he said, and noted the FCA primates council “has also gone far deeper in relationship because of the AMiA crisis and we are far more committed to one another personally than ever before.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Anglican TV Episode 42, June 2, 2012 June 2, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of Canada, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Consultative Council, Anglican Covenant, Anglican.TV, Church of England, Property Litigation, Virginia, Women Priests.Tags: Diamond Jubilee
comments closed
So much news so little time. In this week’s Anglican Unscripted Kevin, George, Peter, and Alan bring you the latest Anglican News. Peter brings news of a Diamond Jubilee and Women Bishops in England. Alan delivers the latest supreme court news from The Falls Church. Kevin and George talk about a cancer in the Anglican Communion and updated betting on the next Archbishop of Canterbury.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 41, May 25, 2012 May 27, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of Australia, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, Church of England, The Episcopal Church.comments closed
This weekend Kevin and George discuss Anglican’s first historian, the Tale of Two Ladies, and AUs new Canterbury Sweepstakes feature. Our Contributors bring news from England, Australia, and the USA. Comments to AnglicanUnscripted@gmail.com To donate to Georges trip to General Convention goto http://www.Anglican.tv/donate
Anglican Unscripted Episode 40: May 21, 2012 May 21, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, ARCIC, Church of England, Church of Ireland, New Hampshire.Tags: Baptism
comments closed
Kevin and George bring news from the Episcopal Church and a General Convention resolution to allow Communion without Baptism. Ireland passes motion 8 during their General Synod despite creative use of Roberts Rules. The Roman Catholic church met with Anglican leaders in Hong Kong for the third time. New Hampshire is going to elect a new Bishop tomorrow. Canon Phil Ashley explains how AMiA Bishops are moving into ACNA and which Canons are helping that transition.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 40: May 21, 2012 May 21, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, ARCIC, Church of England, Church of Ireland, New Hampshire, The Episcopal Church.comments closed
Kevin and George bring news from the Episcopal Church and a General Convention resolution to allow Communion without Baptism. Ireland passes motion 8 during their General Synod despite creative use of Roberts Rules. The Roman Catholic church met with Anglican leaders in Hong Kong for the third time. New Hampshire is going to elect a new Bishop tomorrow. Canon Phil Ashley explains how AMiA Bishops are moving into ACNA and which Canons are helping that transition.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 39, May 11, 2012 May 11, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of Canada, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, Church of Ireland, Property Litigation, The Episcopal Church.comments closed
Kevin and George are at it again. This week they tackle the tough topic of people in purple, The Anglican Mission in America, Same Sex Marriage, and communication in in the church. Peter has breaking news from Ireland and AS Haley brings legal news from Orange Beach California. Comments to AnglicanUnscripted@gmail.com and twitter #au39
Bishop Todd Hunter joins the ACNA: Anglican Ink, May 8, 2012 May 8, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Church of the Congo, Anglican Ink.Tags: Chuck Murphy, Robert Duncan, Todd Hunter
comments closed
Bishop Todd Hunter
Bishop Todd Hunter of the Anglican Mission in America (AMiA) has been received by the Anglican Church in North America and will serve as an assistant bishop in the office of the primate, the Most Rev. Robert Duncan.
On 4 May 2012 the California-based bishop held a conference call with Archbishop Duncan, Bishop Chuck Murphy of the AMiA, and Bishop Terrell Glenn of PEAR-USA/ACNA to discuss his future plans.
Bishop Hunter stated that he had a “warm and collegial conversations” with the three bishops and “articulated for each of them my vision of C4SO becoming a servant to all the various Anglican entities within North America. C4SO will happily plant churches in partnership with PEARUSA, TheAm and the ACNA.”
C4SO – Churches for the Sake of Others – is a church planting initiative run by Bishop Hunter that will now move under the ecclesial oversight of the ACNA.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Anglican Unscripted Episode 38, May 5, 2012 May 6, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican.TV, Archbishop of Canterbury, Church of England, Church of Ireland, Texas, The Episcopal Church.Tags: Andrew Doyle, Chuck Murphy, Harold Miller, Michael Jackson, Robert Duncan
comments closed
The Anglican Four have more news for you. Kevin and George bring you Today-in-History, More of The AMiA breakdown, Erastian Texans, picking Canterbury, and the weather for Ireland is spring. Peter breaks down behind-the-scenes GAFCON and AS Haley has breaking news from Christ Church, Savannah. Oh… and there is a surprise Guest this week.
ACNA receives two AMiA bishops: Anglican Ink, April 30, 2012. May 1, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink.Tags: Diocese of the South, Foley Beach, Gulf Atlantic Diocese, John Miller, Neil Lebahr, TJ Johnstone
comments closed

Bishop Foley Beach
The Anglican Church of North America (ACNA) has received two bishops from the Anglican Mission in America (AMiA) as honorary temporary assistant bishops.
The Rt. Rev. T.J. Johnston will serve as an assistant bishop to the Rt. Rev. Foley Beach of the Anglican Diocese of the South and the Rt. Rev. John Miller will serve as an assistant bishop to the Rt. Rev. Neil Lebahr of the Gulf Atlantic Diocese, Anglican Ink has learned.
A memorandum of understanding dated 18 April 2012 endorsed by Bishops Johnson and Miller and by Bishop Leonard Riches and Charlie Masters on behalf of the ACNA states the agreement serves to “provide a temporary jurisdictional connection” and will last for 180 days, with an interim review at the 90 day mark.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
U.S. property cases may go to the Supreme Court: The Church of England Newspaper, April 6, 2012 p 7. April 10, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper, Connecticut, Fort Worth, Georgia, Property Litigation, Virginia.comments closed
Four of the Episcopal Church’s key property dispute cases have moved to the state and U.S. Supreme Courts for review.
Briefings have been filed in the Episcopal v. Anglican Dioceses of Fort Worth cases in the Texas Supreme Court, while the breakaway congregations in Northern Virginia have asked the Virginia Supreme Court to review the lower court’s ruling giving the diocese custody of the parish properties.
The breakaway congregations in Christ Church v. Diocese of Georgia and Bishop Seabury Church v. Diocese of Connecticut have filed writs of certiorari with the U.S. Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has also been asked to review a third property dispute, Timberridge Presbyterian Church v. the Presbytery of Greater Atlanta, that addresses the same legal issues.
The issue before the courts, as summarized in the Bishop Seabury petition, is whether the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution “requires state civil courts to enforce an alleged trust imposed on local church property by provisions in denominational documents, regardless of whether those provisions would be legally cognizable under generally applicable rules of state property and trust law.”
The American state courts are divided and have made contrary rulings based on their interpretation of Jones v. Wolf. Five state supreme courts and one federal circuit court hand held that denominational property trust rules such as the Episcopal Church’s Dennis Canon should only enforced in civil court if they were in conformance to “objective, well-established concepts of trust and property law,” while four state supreme courts have enforced “denominational documents asserting a trust regardless of whether those documents are other ‘embodied in some legally cognizable form’.”
Canon lawyer Allan Haley noted the legal question being presented to the Supreme Court is the quasi-establishment of one group of churches over others that has arisen since the Jones v. Wolf decision.
In interpreting the Jones decision some state courts have permitted the canon law of the Episcopal Church, and other ‘hierarchical’ churches to take precedence over state law in property disputes. Mr. Haley argued that “no other body or organization — religious or otherwise — has been granted the privilege of creating enforceable trusts in such a unilateral fashion.”
The state court decisions in favour of the Episcopal Church have relied upon obiter dictum (a remark made as an aside, in the course of a decision) made by Justice Blackmun in the Jones case. This remark “suddenly become the law of the land, sufficient to override all state and local laws to the contrary? That is not how the law is supposed to work,” Mr. Haley said.
The “practical effect” has been to grant “special State privileges to just one type of church. And that ‘establishment’ of one type of church over all other types, and over all other kinds of property owners as well, quite plainly is contrary to the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, as applied to the several States through the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution,” Mr. Haley argued.
However, writing in the Washington Post, the Bishop of Virginia, the Rt. Rev. Shannon Johnston argued the issues should be seen through the lens of theology. “We are called to be good stewards of property given to us by our forebears. Stewardship is a theological concept: we give thanks for the gifts God has given to us all. Stewards are bound to preserve gifts for future generations,” the bishop said
“The matter of biblical interpretation is at the heart of the issues, and there are real differences. Differences over biblical interpretation, not authority, remain unsettled. Even so, the common, ancient tradition as to authority, polity and property stands with the diocese and its bishop,” he argued in support of the diocese’s legal campaign.
The Supreme Court is not obligated to hear the petitions from the state courts as four of the justices must agree to hear a case before it is brought before the court. The court is expected to announce whether it will review the church cases at the close of its current term in June or at the start of the next term in October.
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
Bishop Seabury case appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court: Anglican Ink, March 24, 2012 March 24, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Connecticut, Property Litigation.Tags: Bishop Seabury Church, Ronald Gauss
comments closed
The Ven. Ronald Gauss
Bishop Seabury Church in Groton, Conn., has filed a writ of certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court asking for a review of the Connecticut Supreme Court that upheld the Episcopal Church’s Dennis Canon.
Last week lawyers for the former Episcopal Diocese of Connecticut congregation, which now is part of the Anglican Church of North America, filed a 44 page petition with the court asking for review. Only a fraction of the cases appealed to the Supreme Court are reviewed, however there is a likelihood the case may be heard as it covers legal issues addressed in two petitions filed in response to rulings by the Georgia Supreme Court: the case of Christ Church v. the Diocese of Georgia and the case of Timberridge Presbyterian Church v. Presbytery of Greater Atlanta.
A copy of the 12 March 2012 U.S. Supreme Court filing of the case of Gauss v. the Diocese of Connecticut may be found here. A copy of the petition in Timberridge Presbyterian Church v. Presbytery of Greater Atlanta may be found here.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
VA cases conclude: The Church of England Newspaper, March 9, 2012, p 7. March 15, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper, Property Litigation, Virginia.comments closed
A Virginia court has rejected the plea of the state’s Attorney General to revisit his decision granting ownership of the property and assets of seven breakaway congregations. On 1 March 2012, Fairfax County Circuit Court Judge Randy Bellows said the ACNA-affiliated congregations must turn over their properties to the Diocese of Virginia by 30 April 2012.
On 22 Feb 2012, Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli filed a brief in support of a motion filed by the congregations asking the court to reconsider its decision ordering all property be turned over to the diocese including funds donated by parishioners. He argued that donor intent not canon law should govern the disposition of the charitable donations under Virginia law.
Virginia Bishop Shannon Johnston stated he hoped last week’s ruling will “mark the end of this lengthy litigation” and allow the diocese to focus its energies “on mission and ministries.”
A spokesman for the breakaway congregations stated that “while our congregations will comply with the final order, we are saddened that the Circuit Court did not accept the motion for partial reconsideration and we continue to believe that, as a matter of religious liberty, it is the right of donors to restrict the use of their own gifts to the church of their choice.”
We “prayerfully considering their legal options,” said Jim Oakes, the spokesman for the breakaway churches.
The logic used by the court and the Episcopal Church was “Heads we win; tails you lose,” canon law scholar Allan Haley observed.
“The first sentence of the Dennis Canon [the church’s property canon] lets them claim all of the parishes’ property because they could not leave the Church, while the second sentence has to be read to mean the opposite of what it says” to allow the court to reach the finding it did.
“The parish can certainly continue to spend its money to keep up the grounds, the buildings and the mortgage, but they are to receive no credit for having done so and having thereby ensured that the property would still be valuable and in good condition when the Diocese took over possession,” Mr. Haley wrote, stating it was “obvious” the court and the Episcopal Church had not “bothered to think through the consequences of their reasoning.”
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
Virginia cases back in court: The Church of England Newspaper, March 2, 2012, p 5. March 8, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper, Property Litigation, Virginia.comments closed

Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli
The Attorney General of Virginia has filed a motion in the property dispute between the Episcopal Diocese and seven breakaway congregations that have affiliated with the Anglican Church of North America (ACNA) break, asking the court to reconsider its January ruling that all property donated to the churches prior to 31 January 2007 be turned over to the diocese.
On 22 Feb 2012, Attorney General Ken Cuccinelli filed a brief in support of a motion filed by the congregations, asking Judge Randy Bellows to reconsider his decision ordering all property be turned over to the diocese as donor intent governed the disposition of the charitable donations under Virginia law.
Beginning in 2003 the seven congregations permitted their members to designate whether their congregations may be passed on to the national church or the diocese. By 2006 almost all of the donations received by the congregations were restricted by the donors for the use of the congregation. This donor intent governed the disposition of property, the attorney general argued.
In its 27 February response the diocese argued the congregations’ argument had no “legal or factual merit.”
Donor intent has no place in “a neutral principles of law analysis,” the diocese argued, and there is “no violation of religious freedom because no donor is being or has been compelled or coerced to contribute” to the diocese or national church.
Parish spokesman Jim Oakes stated the “core issue” under review was the “right of donors to restrict the use of their own gifts to the church of their choice.”
The parishes believed this was a “religious liberty issue at its core as the courts are not lawfully able to coerce contributions to a specific religious entity against the wishes of the donors. We ask that the court honor the gift restrictions designated by individuals that have faithfully offered their contributions to these congregations,” said Mr. Oakes.
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
Robinson Cavalcanti murdered: Anglican Ink, February 27, 2012 February 27, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Episcopal Church of Brazil, Anglican Ink, Crime.Tags: Robinson Cavalcanti
comments closed

Bishop Robinson Cavalcanti preaching in the U.S.
The Diocese of Recife reports that Bishop Robinson Cavalcanti and his wife were murdered in their home in Olinda in Northeastern Brazil last night. The bishop’s adopted son is alleged to have knifed his parents following a quarrel.
On 26 February 2012, at approximately 10:00 pm the bishop returned to his home in Olinda after having visited a parish earlier in the day. The bishop’s son is alleged to have pulled a knife on his father and stabbed him.
Read it all at Anglican Ink.
So what sort of Anglican are you?: Get Religion, February 18, 2012 February 18, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Get Religion, Press criticism, The Episcopal Church.Tags: New York Times, Vienna Connection
comments closed
I think it is safe to say that until about 30 – 40 years ago very few people would know what an Anglican was.
Identifying yourself as an Episcopalian or a member of the Church of England in the mid-1970s would not generate the blank stare that a declaration of Anglican identity would elicit. There also was not the need to distinguish between the terms. Save for a few obscure groups here and there just about all Anglicans in the United States were members of the Protestant Episcopal Church of the U.S.A.
Likely the question would never arise, for if you were an Anglican (an Episcopalian) you would not be talking about this anyway as religion was one of the three cardinal no’s of polite society — along with sex and money.
I raise these memories of my untroubled youth by way of introducing the question of how reporters should identify those who calls themselves Anglican.
Via the magic of Facebook, commentator Daniel Stoddart directed my attention to a DC-area newspaper, the Vienna Connection, which has a nice story about a new church. The article entitled “Vienna Resident ‘Plants’ a Church” chronicles its story.
The Rev. Johnny Kurcina has formed a congregation that meets on Sunday mornings at the Louise Archer Elementary School cafeteria. Since its start in November, the church appears to be doing well and the write up presents an attractive picture of a young minister with a bright future ahead.
The word “Anglican” is found in the sub-title and the story contains this line. Christ Church is:
run by a Board of Directors, the “church council.” As Pastor of the church, Kurcina heads its future, guided by the deliberations of the church council. Kurcina would like to see more Anglican churches “planted” in the area.
What we are not told is what sort of Anglican Church this is, or if this church is an Anglican Church. And what exactly does it mean to be an Anglican church?
There are clues for the initiated. His church has a “church council” not a vestry. He is its “pastor,” not a rector or vicar. The photo accompanying the story shows Mr. Kurcina in an open necked shirt — no clerical collar. And, we learn that:
In 2005, Kurcina spoke with the senior minister, a friend, of The Falls Church in Falls Church, about the feasibility of opening a church in Vienna. “They have the human resources, the financial resources and a real interest seeing new churches started,” said Kurcina. He became actively involved with The Falls Church, whose history goes back to the early 18th century, intending to “plant” a new church in Vienna.
The Falls Church is/was one of the major Episcopal Churches in Northern Virginia. A majority of its congregation quit the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia and left to join the Anglican Church in North America (ACNA). GetReligion has covered the reporting on this split as well. The clues then would lead a knowledgeable reader to believe this church plant was part of the ACNA — but then again, it may not be as the article is silent on this point.
There is an on-going fight over the Anglican brand in the U.S. between the Episcopal Church and the ACNA. The Episcopal Church is the “official” Anglican franchise in the U.S., but the ACNA is recognized by a majority of the world’s Anglicans too as being a bona fide Anglican church.
The New York Times recently published a correction to one of its stories that addressed this point.
An article on Jan. 2 about the Roman Catholic church’s formation of a new diocese-like entity for breakaway Episcopal priests and congregations misstated the role of the Episcopal Church within the Anglican Communion. The Episcopal Church is the sole official branch of the Anglican Communion in the United States, not “the main American branch.”
This is true up .. up to a point. The Episcopal Church is the sole American member of the Anglican Consultative Council — a pan-Anglican coordinating group whose powers and authority are subject to some debate. But there is no official definition of who is an Anglican so that the claim to be the “sole official branch” is not entirely straightforward.
Compare the Times’ certainty to the uncertainty of the Archbishops of Canterbury and York on this point. In a paper released on 20 January 2012 they noted that the:
the concept of membership of the Anglican Communion is not entirely straightforward. The Communion itself … has no legal personality. In addition (and unlike the Church of England) it does not have a set of canons which set out its core beliefs and regulate aspects of its internal governance.
In other words there is no hard and fast definition of who is an Anglican. The bottom line … the Vienna Connection should have identified what sort of Anglican church Christ Church Vienna was. But asking whether they are real or faux Anglicans is something that even the Archbishops of England have shied away from answering.
Should reporters define their terms? Does an individual’s self-identification take precedence over all? Should reporters question this self-identification? And if so, against what standard? How does the Anglican question compare to the issue of who is a Roman Catholic?
First published in GetReligion.
Take no decision on ACNA, archbishops’ synod paper argues: The Church of England Newspaper, January 27, 2012 p 5. February 2, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Archbishop of Canterbury, Archbishop of York, Church of England, Church of England Newspaper.Tags: Robert Duncan
comments closed
First published in The Church of England Newspaper.
The Anglican Church in North America (ACNA) has welcomed the release of a general synod paper under the signature of the Archbishops of Canterbury and York that addresses the province-in-formation’s relationship to the Church of England.
In a statement released on 21 January 2012, the primate of the ACNA, Archbishop Robert Duncan of Pittsburgh said the province-in-formation was “encouraged by the desire of the Church of England to continue to embrace the Anglican Church in North America and remain in solidarity with us as we proclaim the Gospel message and truth as revealed in Scripture in the way it has always been understood in Anglican formularies.”
The document released online on 20 January 2012 urges inaction upon the synod in defining its relationship to ACNA, but also serves as a backhanded recognition the new North American province is part of the Anglican world.
Synod paper MISC 1011 entitled “The Church of England and the Anglican Church in North America”, comes in response to a private members motion presented to the February 2010 session of synod which asked the archbishops to clarify the Church of England’s relationship with the ACNA. The archbishops responded this question was more properly formulated into three distinct questions.
“What is the range of relationship with other Christian churches that is possible for the Church of England?; How does a particular local Church become accepted as part of the Anglican Communion?; and In what circumstances can the orders of another Church be recognised and accepted by the Church of England so that someone ordained in that church can be given archiepiscopal authorisation for ministry here?”
The archbishops responded that the first and third questions were governed by the canon law of the Church of England. Relations with other churches was governed by the actions of General Synod, the archbishops said, offering examples of the Porvoo Agreements with the Nordic Lutheran Churches, the Methodist Covenant and the Church of England’s links with the provinces of the Anglican Communion.
The reception or licensing of overseas clergy within the Church of England was governed by canon law and the “authorisation by the Archbishop of the Province is considered on a case by case basis and will take a number of relevant considerations into account” before an overseas cleric is licensed to officiate in the Province of York or Canterbury.
In answering the second question, the Archbishops conceded “the concept of membership of the Anglican Communion is not entirely straightforward”, noting the Anglican Communion was not a legal entity governed by statute or bylaws. The archbishops also acknowledged the political failure of the Anglican Consultative Council to create a mutually recognizable Anglican identity.
However, the archbishops did note the concept of an Anglican bishop might be defined by the standard set of who was invited to attend meetings of the Lambeth Conference. In 2008 Dr. Williams declined to extend an invitation to Bishop Martyn Minns of CANA on the grounds that his ministry on behalf of the Church of Nigerian in the United States violated the provincial boundaries of the Episcopal Church.
However, Dr. Williams also declined to invite Bishop Gene Robinson of New Hampshire due to his status as an openly gay bishop – and the archbishop also declined to invite Dr. Nolbert Kunonga of Harare in light of his ties to the Mugabe regime. The Lambeth Conference standard was further weakened as the 2008 meeting differed substantially from its predecessors as it was transformed as a meeting of equals into an extended tutorial session led by the archbishop for the instruction and improvement of the wider communion.
The way forward, the archbishops noted was to maintain relations with the Episcopal Church in the U.S.A. as well as maintain an “open-ended engagement with ACNA on the part of the Church of England and the Communion” – deciding not to decide the issue at this time.
Archbishop Duncan said he appreciated the “work of the Faith and Order Commission of the Church of England, whose report and recommendations to the Archbishops of Canterbury and York form the basis of the document now released for General Synod, and whose content substantially advances the same ends with the Church of England.”
He added that the ACNA had “demonstrated successfully to the GAFCON primates” that it “remains committed to our growing relationships with Anglican provinces outside of North America. Our biblical orthodoxy and ministries are strengthening our bond to our Anglican brothers and sisters around the globe. We are gratified that we are already in a relationship of full communion with many Anglican Provinces and look forward to expanding that circle.”
Anglican Unscripted Episode 25: January 24, 2012 January 27, 2012
Posted by geoconger in AMiA, Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Church of Southern Africa, Anglican Communion, Anglican.TV, Archbishop of Canterbury.comments closed
Not sure how to translate English to American? Kevin and George offer their years of experience in interpreting MISC 1011. They also take a gander at the news of AMiA, PEAR, and Moving Forward. And then there is that History thing.
Diocese of Virginia prevails in parish property case: The Church of England Newspaper, January 13, 2012 p 7. January 16, 2012
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Church of England Newspaper, Property Litigation, Virginia.Tags: John Guernsey, Shannon Johnston
comments closed
First printed in The Church of England Newspaper.
A Virginia circuit court has ruled that the properties of seven breakaway congregations belong to the Episcopal Diocese of Virginia. The 10 January 2012 decision by Judge Randy Bellows comes almost five years after litigation began and millions of dollars expended over the control of seven Northern Virginia congregations.
In his 113-page opinion, Judge Bellows held that national Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Virginia have a “contractual and proprietary” interest in each of the churches. The court “denied in their entirety” the counter-claims of the breakaway congregations, and ordered the congregations to turn over the properties and assets of the congregations acquired before the state of the lawsuits in 2007 to the diocese.
“Our goal throughout this litigation has been to return faithful Episcopalians to their church homes and Episcopal properties to the mission of the Church,” said Bishop Shannon Johnston of Virginia after the verdict was announced.
He added that he was “grateful for the decision in our favor” but was “mindful of the toll this litigation has taken on all parties involved, and we continue to pray for all affected by the litigation.”
A spokesman for the congregations stated “although we are profoundly disappointed by today’s decision, we offer our gratitude to Judge Bellows for his review of this case. As we prayerfully consider our legal options, we above all remain steadfast in our effort to defend the historic Christian faith.”
The Rev. John Yates, rector of The Falls Church, one of the properties involved in the lawsuit stated the “core issue for us is not physical property, but theological and moral truth and the intellectual integrity of faith in the modern world.”
“Wherever we worship, we remain Anglicans because we cannot compromise our historic faith,” Mr. Yates said.
Bishop John Guernsey of the ACNA’s Diocese of the Mid-Atlantic told the seven congregations not to be afraid for the future. “Our trust is in the Lord who is ever faithful. He is in control and He will enable you to carry forward your mission for the glory of Jesus Christ and the extension of His Kingdom. Know that your brothers and sisters in Christ continue to stand with you and pray for you.”
Court victory for Quincy in church property dispute: Anglican Ink, December 21, 2011 December 21, 2011
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Property Litigation, Quincy.Tags: Bishop Alberto Morales
comments closed
Bishop Alberto Morales of Quincy
An Illinois court has dismissed the claim that as a “matter of law” the Episcopal Church is a hierarchical with dioceses being subordinate to the national church, rejecting a motion for summary judgment brought by the national church against the breakaway Diocese of Quincy.
The 16 Dec 2011 decision by Judge Thomas Ortbal of the Eighth Judicial Circuit Court in Adams County, Ill., now sends the dispute between the Diocese of Quincy and the national church and its allies to trial. The court also concluded that even if the church is hierarchical, that would not end the matter because a “neutral principles of law” approach should be applied to resolving the property ownership dispute.
Judge Ortbal’s decision – which cannot be challenged on appeal at this stage of the proceeding without his permission – may well be a legal blow to the national church’s litigation strategy in its fight with other breakaway dioceses as it cuts the legs out from under the national church’s chief legal argument.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
Threat of lawsuit blocks ordinariate vote: Anglican Ink, December 8, 2011 December 8, 2011
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Anglican Ordinariate, Fort Worth.comments closed
An ACNA congregation in Fort Worth has been blocked by the threat of litigation from holding a parish vote on whether it would accept Pope Benedict XVI’s invitation to enter into full communion with Rome through the Anglican Ordinariate.
On 8 Dec 2011, Bishop Jack Iker announced that scheduled vote by the congregation of St Timothy’s Church in Fort Worth had been cancelled following the intervention of the national Episcopal Church.
Bishop Iker stated that on 6 Dec “lawyers for the Episcopal Church parties delivered a letter to our legal team inquiring about the situation at St. Timothy and commenting that the proposed use of the St. Timothy property by a body from another denomination would not be a ‘normal course of business use’ in compliance with the order of the 141st District Court signed Oct. 20, 2011.”
The diocese’s lawyers were asked “to explain how the situation would be handled to be in compliance with the order to avoid a hearing before the court, or the TEC lawyers indicated they would proceed to bring the matter to the court’s attention.”
Read it all in Anglican Ink.
No left behind fears in Fort Worth: Anglican Ink, December 5, 2011 December 5, 2011
Posted by geoconger in Anglican Church of North America, Anglican Ink, Anglican Ordinariate, Fort Worth.Tags: Christopher Stainbrook, Jack Iker
comments closed
St Timothy's Fort Worth
The vicar of the Fort Worth congregation that is set to depart for Rome believes his entire congregation will accept the pope’s offer of the Anglican Ordinariate.
The Rev. Christopher Stainbrook, SSC told Anglican Ink “we don’t think there will be any remnant which wishes to remain a part of the ACNA Diocese of Fort Worth.”
On 2 December 2011 the Rt. Rev. Jack. L. Iker announced that the vicar and bishops’ committee – the term for a vestry in a mission congregation supported by a diocese – had petitioned the Vatican for the congregation of St Timothy’s to be received en masse into the Roman Catholic Church under the provisions of the Anglican Ordinariate.
Read it all in Anglican Ink.